The Good: A rich
community of characters, a beautiful depiction of provincial France, the French
perspective on a major World War II turning point, a writing style that makes
France during the Nazi occupation seem somehow fairy tale-esque.
The Bad: Needs more
exposition. In a book full of “are
things as they seem?” with the small and large acts of resistance from the
occupied villagers, I was dying for a little more “this is the rest of the
story on X character.”
The Verdict: I like Stephen Kiernan’s books, enough to give
them four stars on Goodreads, but there’s always just a little something
missing that keeps me from all-out loving them.
I loved all the parts of this book but, as a whole, it just falls the
tiniest bit short. That said, I wouldn’t
hesitate to recommend The Baker’s Secret. It’s a welcome addition to the World
War II historical fiction genre I love so much.
Review copy received from the publisher.
I know what you mean about books like that but I still enjoy them.
ReplyDeleteI really loved his The Hummingbird. And I enjoyed The Curiosity, although I didn't love it. I'm looking forward to this one. It'll be interesting to see if I have the same issue with it as you.
ReplyDeleteI hadn't heard of this one but a look of the German occupation in France that's not all dismal and bleek sounds good to me.
ReplyDeleteThis definitely sounds like a book I would like. I'm going to stick it on my never-ending Goodreads TBR list, which means I should get to it in about, oh, 2080 :)
ReplyDelete